Hi, I’m Kristin, a Recovering Creative Director Relearning How to be Creative
What kind of a person leaves a career they love?
Did you ever dream of a title and a role? For me it was Creative Director. After 18 years as a designer in advertising, a career I loved, working with incredible people, truly enjoying most of the things that were in my job description, why would I walk away? I had finally achieved my own peak dream title of Creative Director. It’s really everything I wanted. Leading a team of designers I truly cared about working for good clients, doing work that felt good. I was the person everyone needed to talk to. The hub of the wheel. The glue of my team.
Best of all, I was directing about seven photoshoots a year. Wine and food focused photoshoots with a fantastic photographer, Emily Baker, with our own beloved team of art directors, producers, and project managers and working in our own photo studio. The shoots were mostly all female and we had so much fun and worked so hard. It felt like project runway and for an art nerd like me this was a perfect blend of stress, excitement and creative production.

Some of my favorite people in the business, in the photo studio
So What Went Wrong?
When you do work for a brand, the most important thing is that it looks like and strengthens that brand. If the colors are supposed to be bright and energetic, then you are never going to be using a moody deep blue, or a dark and dramatic photo. You stay in your lane (the lane of your brand). This is fun for a year or two, as you get to know the brand and really get inside it. Then you push it further into being more of itself. You are growing and deepening your understanding. You push the limits a bit. You get your hand slapped a little and pull back. Stay in your lane.
This is all the way it should be. Also, when you are a creative person who is interested in experimentation and curious about what’s new and cool in the world of design and art and advertising, it KILLS your soul a little every day. You stay positive for your team and your clients because that is your whole job. No problem. We are not making art here. This is advertising and we are selling a product.
The Thing About the Money
There was a line in Madmen – where Peggy complained to Don (her boss) that he didn’t give her credit for her work when it won an award. He replied coldly that she was too young to have earned the credit. That she did the work and got paid for it. And that was the agreement: That’s what the money is for!

This rings so true. As you get paid more in advertising, the less attached you can get to the feeling that what you made was really good. And maybe you don’t even want to take credit for it. Advertising design is always in service of the sales goals, the KPIs and the ROI. You always need to find a way to do more for less. And do it faster. And could you also look into training AI to do your job for us?
It’s a hard business to be in. I’m just a weird shy person who likes art a lot.
Weird shy/people
As a weird shy girl to my core, being an art director and creative director – in terms of working with other creatives – was wish fulfillment on a spiritual level. I got to work every day with a small group of people who I’m guessing were also weird shy people at their cores. I loved the collaboration and teaching and knowledge sharing that went on. I love helping others do their best work. It is SO rewarding on a human level.
Here’s the Thing About Being a Creative Director.
You do the thing: dive in to create concept ideas, vying with your team to see whose is selected, then you make the designs, plan and art direct the photo shoot, review and provide feedback for the photo retouching, direct and provide feedback for the design work, keep your clients updated and then preset the work. This is the good part. The part I was built to do.
Then you have to explain how you did the thing. Show how you did the thing. Show how it benefits the client.
The thing is, the creative part of the role, leading client conversations, and an internal team, leading and directing about 7 photo shoots a year was a joy. But it seemed like the other parts of the role never got comfortable. Not the part where you and your team do the work and present it to the client and move through refinements until it meets all of the requirements and then some.—the other part was where I had to tell other people what we did. The layers of approvals. And then the client always has the final say. You develop the ability to detach yourself from the creative you make. And after many years of doing that, It just doesn’t feel like it’s even possible to find anything to love about what you are making.

That was me. I promise there was a valid reason I was under the table
After 18 years, I felt hollow. I could no longer allow myself to feel any connection to the work I was making. Because none of it was for me. None of it was what I wanted to be making. It seems obvious now, but when I was in the middle of it, all I knew was that I was SO TIRED.
Eventually it wore me down and wore me out.
So I Did What Every Virgo Does Best. I Made a Plan.
A spread sheet to track monthly expenses, color coded for essential and just fun. It was not a snap decision. More like a one-year off ramp. Saving money and trudging through. Counting down the days, growing my savings account. Until my final day when I gave my notice. My supervisor was really kind and supportive, and we made a plan for my transition to make sure my team and our clients were.
So, who do I think I am?
Honestly, I’m not sure yet. I’m someone who loved a career and left it. I’m hopeful, a little scared, and excited about what comes next. And I’m trying to remember what it feels like to make something just because I want to.
That’s what this space is for.
To be continued…


